Top 10 Roofing Companies
in Toledo, OH

Pro Craft has roofed Toledo continuously since 1952, which is longer than almost anyone in Northwest Ohio, and holds the credential that matters most in this particular city: Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status, maintained unbroken from 2019 through 2026 and held by fewer than one percent of contractors nationally. That designation unlocks a system warranty covering shingles, underlayment, ventilation, and starter strips together with workmanship errors, rather than shingles alone. They have also taken the Owens Corning Product Excellence Award in multiple years and hold Roser and Decra certifications. Two operational commitments set them apart: they run their own crews on every job with no subcontractors, and they pull City of Toledo permits on every replacement rather than treating it as optional. Phones are answered around the clock.

Floyd Holt founded this company in 1947, his son Jack took over in 1969, and it remains family-run under Mark and Beth Holt today. Its BBB accreditation dates to April 1974 — more than fifty unbroken years, the longest accreditation record we found anywhere in Ohio — and it won the BBB Torch Award for Marketplace Ethics in 2008. The practical reason to call Holt is breadth of roofing system: alongside shingles and metal they install and repair TPO, EPDM, PVC, modified bitumen, built-up, and roof coatings, and they are a Carlisle Certified Installer. If your Toledo property has a flat or low-slope section, a porch roof, or a mixed system, this is the contractor on the list with genuine membrane expertise rather than a shingle crew improvising.

Toledo native Adam Becker founded Integrity in 2000, and the company has held BBB accreditation with an A+ rating since July 2003. Their differentiator is the Gold Standard Protection Plan, which carries lifetime workmanship coverage plus free annual inspections — the strongest workmanship position of any contractor on this list, and the annual inspection piece is genuinely valuable in a market where ice dam damage compounds quietly over several winters. They work with Owens Corning and Atlas products across roofing, siding, windows, doors, gutters, and attic insulation. Weekday hours run to 8PM and they open Saturday mornings, which is unusual in this market and useful if you cannot take time off work for an estimate.

Roofing419 has built a decade-plus reputation in the Toledo market across roof replacement, new installs, metal and asphalt shingle work, and emergency repairs. Their award record is the reason to take them seriously: a Best of Toledo award in 2017 and Marketplace Ethics Awards in both 2016 and 2023. Winning an ethics award twice, seven years apart, is a meaningfully different signal from a single recognition — it suggests the standard held as the company grew. They also carry Owens Corning Platinum Preferred certification, the same top-one-percent designation as Pro Craft, which means they can offer the full Owens Corning system warranty including workmanship coverage. Their name is a deliberate nod to the 419 area code and local identity.

4 Guys and a Roof installs Owens Corning materials exclusively, and their reasoning is specific to this city: Owens Corning’s world headquarters sits in downtown Toledo, so when a shingle defect appears they can take it directly to the manufacturer rather than working through a distributor chain. That is a real advantage almost no other US market offers. They publish unusually detailed local pricing, including neighbourhood-level ranges across Toledo, Maumee, Sylvania, and Perrysburg, and they call out the industry practice of quoting low to win the job then recovering margin through change orders. Their content emphasises the components most estimates hide — quality underlayment, ice and water shield, ridge vent systems, and flashing — which are precisely the items that determine whether a Toledo roof survives ice dam season.

Ace Roofing and Construction serves the Toledo area with an emphasis on the licensing and insurance question that matters more here than in most markets. They are explicit that fly-by-night operators and storm chasers underbid precisely because they skip liability insurance, workers’ compensation, and the state and local licenses Toledo requires — and that an uninsured worker injured on your property can become your financial problem. That framing is worth taking seriously regardless of who you ultimately hire. They publish 2026 Toledo cost guidance in the $8,000 to $20,000 range and walk through what actually drives the variation, rather than quoting a single headline figure.

Salgau has worked the Toledo metro since 1998, giving it more than 27 years of continuous local operation from a genuine East Toledo address on Starr Avenue. They handle asphalt shingle and EPDM flat roof replacement, which covers both the pitched and low-slope sections common on older Toledo housing. The recurring theme in independent reviews is speed and price: homeowners who collected three estimates repeatedly report Salgau coming in competitive, and describe replacements finished efficiently — often within an afternoon — with thorough cleanup and minimal disruption. If you are cost-conscious and your project is a straightforward tear-off and replacement rather than a complex specialty job, they are worth including in your bid set.

Seagate is the only contractor on this list combining roofing with basement and foundation repair, and in Toledo that pairing makes more sense than it might elsewhere. Water problems in older Toledo homes frequently involve both ends of the building at once: failed gutters and roof drainage dumping water against a foundation that then leaks into the basement. Diagnosing that as one system rather than two separate contractor visits can save a homeowner from fixing the symptom twice. Alongside roofing they handle siding and gutters. Reviewers cite knowledgeable inspectors, professional crews, prompt inspection scheduling, and clear written estimates.

Salinas is a family-owned Toledo contractor covering roofing, siding, gutters, and windows, and it consistently appears at the top of Yelp’s Toledo roofing listings. The recurring praise centres on responsiveness and job-site discipline: homeowners describe fast callbacks, clean sites, quick turnarounds, and flexible scheduling. They work with both quality asphalt shingle and metal roofing products. For a homeowner who wants a single contractor handling roof and siding together on a mid-sized suburban home, and who values a contractor who actually answers the phone, Salinas is a reasonable shortlist addition alongside the more heavily credentialed firms above.

Mills is included specifically for insurance-funded storm work rather than as a general recommendation. Founded in 1946 and operating from a Maumee office serving the Toledo market, they position themselves as a dedicated storm restoration contractor and state that most of their roof replacements are covered by insurance. Their teams are trained specifically to identify hidden wind and hail damage and to walk homeowners through the claims process, and they work with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, and TAMKO products. The tradeoff is worth being clear about: this is a large multi-market operator headquartered in Troy, Michigan, with offices across Michigan and Ohio, so you get claims depth rather than the owner-level accountability of a small Toledo firm.